UPDATE: It seems as if the first 10 complaints filed in march have been reviewed by the ITC, and the ITC has shot down 8 of the 10 patents and found HTC guilty of violating 2 of them. With 10 more still up for evaluation.
U.S. Patent No. 5,946,647 on a “system and method for performing an action on a structure in computer-generated data” – such as recognizing of phone numbers.
U.S. Patent No. 6,343,263 on a “real-time signal processing system for serially transmitted data”
Both patents seem to be over 15 years old and very generic.
As always, Apple is requesting a ban on all imports of HTC products. But don’t fret, HTC is expected to file a claim for an appeal. We may just have to wait for some time, occupying ourselves with other things such as partypoker and our other electronic devices. And Motorola is already working on getting those patents invalidated by the UPSTO.
If worse comes to show, HTC still has another trick up their sleeve in the form of S3 Graphics which it acquired recently. A few month back, Apple has been found in violation of (2) S3 Graphics patents by the ITC. Thus if the appeal fails, and Motorola is unable to invalidate those patents, HTC can always hold these 2 patents as a bargaining chip to achieve a cross licensing deal.
—–
So today Apple files a new patent complaint with the International Trade Commission looking to block the sale of several HTC devices it claims infringe on Apple patent. Apple recently filed a similar complaint with te ITC looking to block several Samsung smartphones and tablets. Apple feels that Samsung and HTC are copying the iPhone and iPad devices. The move was the latest in an ongoing legal battle between Samsung and Apple surrounding multiple patent disputes.
Apple’s patent disputes with HTC date back even further, however Apple filed first with a patent complaint against the Taiwan-based smartphone maker in early 2010. HTC responded by denying claims that it was infringing on Apple Patents, and the HTC later filed a counter suit in May 2010 alleging that Apple was in fact infringing on five of its patents.
The ITC Lawyer said ealier this year that siding with HTC in the patent disputes was best for the public, and today’s filing suggests that Apple is undeterred by the lawyer’s recent comments.
So what do you think is Apple just making these arguments to stay top-dog i nthe phone world? Or are companies like HTC, Samsung (and others possibly) really infringing on Apple’s patents? You tell us PPCGeekers!
Source: BGR
© 2011, JasonFieldz. All rights reserved.


ha ha ha.. Apple feeling the pressure and is coming out with gunz loaded.. For those people that love Apple.. That’s why you pay high prices for your device… they spend it all on lawyers.
Does Apply think they are the only smart phone vendor in the game? Instead of crying home to mom, improve your product / software and get it in the hands of more and more consumers. I don’t get to let my kid kick everyone else out of the sandbox because he wants to play with anybody else seems like the ITC needs to tell Apple to play the game like everyone else or go home and stop producing
The whole patent system is flawed anyway, and these are all just signs of it. That’s all these big companies seem to do anymore…is sue each other.
That’s why Apple sucks! They do not want to be out done by anybody else! I hope they lose all their frivolous lawsuits and they should be sited with LAWSUIT ABUSE!
haha apple is full of sh!t as usual ..
Computer/IT/Internet Bubble -> Housing/Credit Bubble -> Patent/Merging Bubble..lol
Cause I’ve never seen so many lawsuits about these kind of things as in this 2 years…I know they happen all the time and its nothing new…but its becoming a lot more rampart and getting a lot more attention…
Aka companies are out of ideas and are just suing each other, buying each other out, merging..you name it just to stay afloat :/
Yeah – well I hope that eventually they wake up and see that it is flawed. Sadly if this continues and apple does win a lawsuit that means no more phones by that said company (Samsung, HTC up right now)…Who knows if Nokia omes back big with WP7, we could see the same thing against Nokia… Time will tell – but I hope that the ITC sees this happening and stops it – then fixes the system
@JasonFieldz, The ITC is not going to approve it 100%..and I doubt they will be fixing anything…
If any company looses in court its either going to end up in paying money or cross licensing…most likely cross licensing…no one is going off the shelf any time soon…
Apple overcharges to do stupid things like this… HTC has been making smartphones since 1999, Apple just came in recently, now they want to own the whole market???…
Apple get innovation and stop making the same phone every 6 months…
The real problem is that the government needs to rewrite the rules dealing with patents because the system is broken. Maybe if those idiots in congress didn’t blow trillions on fake wars than we would have enough money here to take care of our own country.
“So what do you think is Apple just making these arguments to stay top-dog in the phone world?”
bah, who say’s they’re top tog!? Not for long in any case if you believe they were…
At least HTC and Samsung can create more than 1 model a year. That’s pathetic. Original iPhone with no 3G was released June 29, 2007. Underpowered 3G on July 11, 2008. 3GS on June 19, 2009 which was basically the 3G with minor updates. iPhone 4 released June, 2010 with antenna issues, but praise it in ads for it’s apps (which can be developed for other OSes), it’s screen resolution which for the past 3 generations was way behind others and only matches them currently, and that’s pretty much it.
Now here we are July 11, 2011 with no mention of another model this year. Still trying to get people to purchase a phone that’s over a year old. The world is moving on.
Apple wants to block other because they can’t keep up.
I believe that if it wasn’t for apple, we wouldn’t have the smartphone competition that is out there today. That being said, apple can’t automatically assume that every new smartphone out there is trying to copy off of them. If I’m not mistaken, apple’s new OS update includes widgets in the lockscreen, which is something that android phone apps did without any jailbreaking. Oh how far the apple has fallen off the tree! For shame iphone…..for shame!
@raybass26gq, We can look at it both ways…if iphone didn’t come out winmo may have lived and it would have been winmo vs android for the top smartphone spot..
As for Apple..its the company that sued NYC for using an Apple to represent “Big Apple” (which was used for almost 100 years)..they are in their own fantasy world from day 1…
I think that they are just hinting about their stock value…LOL, to me, it screams “SELL”
A second complaint was filed by Apple, just yesterday against HTC again. Not sure if that was just before, or right after Apple’s Chief Patent Lawyer QUIT!!! LOL. But anyhow, sounds like even the guy in charge of battling this for them, knows when being a bully is just plain wrong.
I’m glad to see all the members here staying objective and not attacking Apple for their choice in filing a lawsuit. Greed, inferior products, lack of innovation, fear of losing market share, blah, blah, blah.
How can you guys call Apple users Apple fanboys and then turn around and act the same way about HTC? Yeah, the word you are looking for is hypocrite.
Oh yeah, now feel free to bash on me for speaking the truth. Good luck, because I could give a fuck what you HTC ass clowns think.
@rainfreak,
I’m startin to dislike HTC and thier quality control measures. Just about every HTC phone I have owned has had either asthetic flaws or other internal problems.
Apple makes great looking products and that’s about it. I just can’t justify mortgaging my paid off home to purchase a new macbook..er…iphone…ooops…ipod….
@rainfreak, Hypocrite my ass. For me I like HTC as I have had good luck with them over the years. Would I go with a different brand if it offered more, yes? I used to be a WM user and now I’m into Android. I have a PC at home and I own a 4th gen IPOD touch. So I like the IPod and the IPhone is not a bad device but I don’t drop on my knees for Mr. Jobs like some of the die-hard Apple morons. The same morons who get features we had 3 years later and think it’s great. They still don’t get the fact that they are last and Apple copies off other platforms just like everyone else. We have a lot of macs at work and they just plain suck, always problems when we have no problems with the PC’s. I am an engineer for a major television studio; all I can say is Apple sold us millions of dollar’s worth of crap they couldn’t even get to work right. It’s now all in a dumpster, we should be suing Apple for the millions they stole from us. Steve Jobs is a bully and a piece of shit, he’s suing because the stock is dropping and he has no more ideas, he’s a looser. Apple Sucks – Think Scam!!!
@lightman02, couldn’t agree more
@lightman02,
Their stock is dropping? Check again…
http://www.investorguide.com/stock-charts.php?ticker=AAPL
@rainfreak, http://www.businessinsider.com/heres-why-apples-stock-is-dropping-2011-6
@rainfreak, To be fair though..name 1 time HTC went out to sue someone else before they sued them?
At the end of the day..in these kind of lawsuits, we the consumer loose! because these costs get trickled down to us…
I mean lets turn this way around..lets say every company suddenly decides to team up and sue apple..forcing Apple to pay $100 in licensing fees extra for each device sold..who do you think will end up hurt? the people that buy the Apple products…same thing in this case…no matter who wins, in the long run its a loose/loose for us the consumers…
I mean I can understand if they were suing for things like technology patents and etc..but when they are suing for dumb things like generic name, icons, and just for using an Apple in your picture…there comes a point where its going “too far”..and I don’t care if its Apple, HTC, or Samsung or any other company..when they sue for dumb things like this they are just wasting tax payer’s money for no reason…
@rainfreak, Don’t think you made your trolling obvious enough there. lol
I suppose I shouldn’t laugh at the fact that they tried to file a patent on App Store in 2008, which was denied. So then they later attack an Adult App Store for using the term. Followed by attacking Amazon and also GetJar, all for the same term.
Just seems like they are filing lawsuits in the same fashion they make handsets.
Same crap, different day….guess we all have our own opinion.
Great Lawsuit War of 2011!!!!
Ga-zing!
Don’t think you made your trolling obvious enough. lol
@saibot, oops, cancel that. Was supposed to go to rainfreak’s dumbass rant.
@saibot, So it is trolling now to have an opinion that differs from what was stated?
@cataclysm13, Of course it is. On PPCG, if you are an Apple user, you are a small minority, and we all know how the mass public treats the small minority.
Now, if you’ll please excuse me, I have to go pick cotton for my master.
@rainfream, whoa damn dude its not THAT serious.
@cataclysm13, No, but if you look up the definition of trolling his post matched it exactly. It wasn’t a differing opinion. It was an attack on most members here.
Sorry Apple you dont rule the world.
I bet Apple will copy HTC Log in Ring and the spinning Corossal that is on the 3D now.
Microsoft should sue Apple claiming they infringed the concept of a touch capable smartphone, since they already sold them as WM devices.
Oh no wait, Samsung and HTC already sold them BEFORE Apple did, too.
I’m actually glad Anonymous hacked Apple, they deserve it with their shenanigans. I say, screw Jobs.
ITC rules HTC violated two Apple patents…
http://9to5mac.com/2011/07/15/itc-rules-htc-violated-two-of-apples-patents/
All you HTC fanboys and Apple haters can SUCK IT!!
@rainfreak, as I said above in your cotton picking comment. its not all that serious.
@eric12341, and im not even an HTC fanboy im a company that makes software/hardware that meets my needs fanboy.
@rainfreak,
somebody needs a time out sheesh it ain’t that serious besides how many times has apple tried to sue someone and fail ..
@rainfreak, Yeah, read the patents. They are from 1996 and 1994. Long before Apple ever thought about the phone market. The only reason Apple brought them up was because they were scared of the competition and threw every patent possible into the ring.
You can suck it too since the real loser here is the consumer if competition is not allowed.
From my understanding from a CNN article I read this is all over software that when you see a phone number on a webpage it gives you a link to call the number. Apple is claiming they have a patent on that. If that is so why are they singling out android and HTC? I used to have a windows mobile phone that could do the same thing. Why not sue Microsoft too then? Looks like Apple isn’t making enough money off their crappy overpriced products so they ae trying to make money off of other companies products.
@xxxjdoggxxx, Actually, Apple is doing great on profit which is why they can afford to buy the system. They have a much higher price markup than HTC. They cannot take out Microsoft. In fact Microsoft and Oracle are also attacking Android. If this continues, Android will be a thing of the past. iOS and WP7 will then steal all the ideas Android had. A bit ironic.
Maybe if Apple made good products they wouldn’t have to sue to stop people from competing with them!
Read somewhere that Apple suing Samsung/HTC was to deter other smaller companies from trying to enter smartphone business… Kind of like saying I’ll pick a fight with any and everyone so don’t make me go after you type of thing.
Apple knows it won’t win but it’ll make the smaller competitions think about trying to move in.
iPhone carriers are using tiered data plans now which is bound to hurt iphone sells too since iPhone depends so much on it’s app store for it’s selling point.
Couldn’t edit to add more to post lol
But Apple is kind of being crowded out overseas (Not US) from other phone makers. Also read that prepaid is more common than the 2 year contracts so iphone with it’s high data usage means it won’t be as popular for it’s app store. Meaning it can only depend on it’s design/form and trying to bully smaller companies from cloning/copying it. Yes I say clone/copy (not that Samsung/HTC does) but overseas (China/Korea) there are blatant iphone knockoffs… So kind of makes sense that Apple would target Samsung/HTC being that they are big and from that region of the world to deter the smaller companies.
Not saying that it makes sense logically, but it does if you have a bully mentality of a middle schooler…
Stupid Apple. I hate anything Apple cause they clam down on everything to batteries. Otherwise I might consider them.
BUT dont forget this, without Apple, everything would be overseas again like other consumer electronics.
So …